OLD JOKE, Cold War era:
An American and a Pole are comparing the levels of freedom in their two countries.
"Look," says the American, "in my country, we have freedom of speech. If I want to, I can march right up to the White House and yell, 'President Reagan is an S-O-B!' and nothing will happen to me."
"So?" responds the Pole. "I can march up to Gen. Jaruzelski's palace in Warsaw, and yell, 'Reagan is an S-O-B!' and nothing will happen to me, either."
No joke, post-Cold War era:
A Pole named Stanislaw Bartosinski, riding the bus home from work, gets into a heated argument about politics with another passenger. Riled up, Bartosinski calls President Lech Walesa the Polish version of "son of a bitch." He is arrested and put on trial. Under Article 270(1) of the Polish Penal Code, anyone who "publicly insults, ridicules, or derides" the Polish nation or its head of state can be prosecuted, convicted, and punished.
On Aug. 28, Bartosinski is given a one-year suspended sentence and fined 3 million zlotys. That's more than the average Pole takes home in a month.
"I will pay this fine," Bartosinski says, "though I don't know where I'll get the money. But I'll always bear in mind what democracy is in Poland."
In 1798 — when America's democracy was scarcely older than Poland's is now — the Federalist Congress passed, and Federalist President John Adams signed, four federal statutes known collectively as the Alien and Sedition Acts. These laws criminalized any criticism of government officials made "with the intent to defame" them or bring them "into contempt or disrepute."
Ten Republican supporters of Thomas Jefferson were convicted, fined, and imprisoned under the new acts. Vermont Congressman Matthew Lyon, who published a pamphlet criticizing Adams, was jailed.
Republicans mobilized against the "Federalist Reign of Terror," denouncing the Alien and Sedition Acts as appalling violations of the First Amendment. Voters agreed. Outrage mounted, and the Federalist Party collapsed. In 1800, Jefferson was elected president, and his Republican allies won control of Congress. For the next 25 years, the party the Federalists had tried to suppress dominated American politics.
Needless to say, John Adams was a great hero of America's independence, just as Walesa is of Poland's. But even hearts that beat passionately for liberty can be tempted by the urge to stifle dissent. Two hundred years ago in America, the party in power succumbed to that temptation and ended up on the ash heap of history. As ruling parties flex their muscles in the new democracies of today, they might ponder the fate of the Federalists. Get too cavalier with the people's freedom, and your days in office may be numbered.
(Jeff Jacoby is the Boston Herald's chief editorial writer.)

